hakorune/docs/archive/proposals/scope-reuse.md

Scope Reuse Blocks (MVP Proposal)

Status: Historical

Status: design-only during the feature‑pause (no implementation)

Summary

• Give short, reusable logic a name within the current scope without promoting it to a top-level function.
• Keep the core small: block body + postfix header sugar; desugar to local function + normal calls.
• Zero runtime cost: lowers to let/if/call/ret only (no new instructions/closures).

Syntax (postfix header; Nyash style)

• Block form (multi-statement):

  { /* BODY */ } scope name(arglist?) (-> Ret)?
  // call within the same scope
  name(args)
  

• Expression form (one-liner):

  => EXPR  scope name(arglist?) (-> Ret)?
  

Semantics

• Visibility: name is local to the defining scope; not exported.
• Capture: by reference by default. Mutating captured vars requires explicit mut on those bindings.
• Recursion: disallowed in MVP (can be lifted later).
• Errors/exits: same as regular functions (return/cleanup/catch apply at the function boundary).

Lowering (desugaring)

• Transform into a local function plus a local binding for convenience calls.

  // { BODY } scope check(a:Int)->Str
  // ↓ (conceptual)
  let __cap_me = me; let __cap_locals = { /* needed refs */ };
  method __scope_check__(a:Int)->Str {
    return BODY
  }
  let check = (x) => __scope_check__(x)
  

• Captures are passed via hidden arguments or an environment box; no new VM opcodes.

Examples

{ if x % 2 == 0 { return "even" } return "odd" } scope parity(x:Int)->StringBox

for i in range(0,10) {
  print(parity(i))
}

Safety rules (MVP)

• Capture: read-only by default; writes allowed only when the captured binding is declared mut.
• Name uniqueness: scope name must be unique within the scope.
• No cross-scope escape: values may be returned but the function reference itself is not exported.

Observability & Tooling

• Add trace toggles (design only):
  • NYASH_SCOPE_TRACE=1|json to emit enter/exit and capture lists as JSONL.
  • Example: { "ev":"enter","sid":42,"caps":["me","cfg","mut total"] }.
• Lints (design only):
  • Single-use scope → suggest inline.
  • Excess captures → suggest narrowing.

Interactions

• Works with guard/with/await sugars (it’s just a call).
• Compatible with ASI and postfix aesthetics; no new top-level keywords beyond scope suffix.

Tests (syntax-only smokes; design)

• scope_basic: called twice → same result.
• scope_capture_read: reads me/foo.
• scope_capture_mut: mutation only allowed when mut is present.
• scope_with_catch_cleanup: postfix catch/cleanup applied at local-function boundary.

Pause note

• This is documentation and design intent only. Implementation is deferred until after the feature‑pause (post‑bootstrap).