hakorune/phase78-bindingid-promoted-carriers.md at 92b3c2afb51e63226d99e5ff97f7a4366dbf7ead

Files

nyash-codex 8b48bec962 feat(joinir): Phase 78 - BindingId infrastructure for promoted carriers (dev-only)

Phase 78 adds infrastructure to assign BindingIds to synthetic promoted
carriers (e.g., is_digit_pos, is_ch_match), enabling type-safe promoted
variable lookup without string-based naming conventions.

Key Changes:
1. CarrierVar.binding_id field (dev-only):
   - Added Option<BindingId> to track BindingId for each carrier
   - Updated all constructors and struct instantiations

2. CarrierBindingAssigner Box (new file, 273 lines):
   - Allocates BindingIds for promoted carriers via builder.allocate_binding_id()
   - Records original → promoted mapping in promoted_bindings
   - Sets binding_id field on promoted CarrierVar
   - Includes 3 comprehensive unit tests

3. ConditionEnv.register_carrier_binding() (new method):
   - Registers carrier BindingId → ValueId mappings
   - Enables type-safe lookup via binding_id_map

4. Logging cleanup:
   - Gated 6 eprintln! statements with NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG
   - Unified logging tags to [binding_pilot/*]

Design Decisions:
- Promoters create CarrierInfo, lowering code assigns BindingIds
- CarrierBindingAssigner called from Pattern2/4 lowering (has builder access)
- Clear documentation prevents misuse (promoters lack builder access)

Files modified (18):
- carrier_info.rs: binding_id field added to CarrierVar
- carrier_binding_assigner.rs: New Box for BindingId allocation
- condition_env.rs: register_carrier_binding() method
- mod.rs: Module exports
- pattern2_with_break.rs, pattern4_with_continue.rs: Updated for binding_id
- loop_body_*_promoter.rs: Logging cleanup + binding_id in structs
- phase78-bindingid-promoted-carriers.md: Architecture documentation

Tests: 970/970 PASS (zero regressions)
Status: Infrastructure complete, integration deferred to Phase 79

Next Phase: Wire CarrierBindingAssigner in Pattern2/4 lowering + E2E tests

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

2025-12-13 16:20:33 +09:00

3.0 KiB

Raw Blame History

Phase 78: BindingId for Promoted Carriers (dev-only)

Goal

Make LoopBodyLocal promotion (DigitPos/Trim) BindingId-aware without relying on fragile name-based hacks like format!("is_{}", name).

This phase introduces a dev-only identity link:

BindingId(original LoopBodyLocal) → BindingId(promoted carrier) → ValueId(join carrier param)

Problem

Promotion creates synthetic carrier names (例: is_digit_pos, is_ch_match) that do not exist as source-level bindings.

PromotedBindingRecorder expects both original/promoted names in MirBuilder.binding_map.
For promoted carriers this is not true by construction.
For LoopBodyLocal variables, promotion can happen before their local is lowered, so the original name may also be absent.

Solution (current state)

1) CarrierVar gets optional BindingId (dev-only)

src/mir/join_ir/lowering/carrier_info.rs
- CarrierVar.binding_id: Option<BindingId> (feature normalized_dev)

2) CarrierBindingAssigner box

src/mir/join_ir/lowering/carrier_binding_assigner.rs
- Ensures both sides have BindingIds:
  - If original_name is missing in builder.binding_map, allocate a temporary BindingId.
  - If promoted_carrier_name is missing, allocate a temporary BindingId.
- Records:
  - carrier_info.promoted_bindings[original_bid] = promoted_bid
  - CarrierVar.binding_id = Some(promoted_bid) for the promoted carrier
- Restores builder.binding_map after recording (synthetic names do not leak into the source map).

3) Pattern2/Pattern4 wiring

Pattern2 (break): src/mir/builder/control_flow/joinir/patterns/pattern2_with_break.rs
- Calls CarrierBindingAssigner::assign_promoted_binding() immediately after promotion.
- Registers BindingId → ValueId via ConditionEnv.register_carrier_binding() after carrier join_id allocation.
- Keeps legacy name-based aliasing (digit_pos → is_digit_pos) for now, but removes local “guess naming” by using the promoted carrier name returned by the promoter.
Pattern4 (continue): src/mir/builder/control_flow/joinir/patterns/pattern4_with_continue.rs
- Calls CarrierBindingAssigner::assign_promoted_binding() after promotion (analysis metadata only, since Pattern4’s current lowering path does not use JoinValueSpace params).

Tests

Unit test (dev-only): src/mir/builder/control_flow/joinir/patterns/pattern2_with_break.rs
- phase78_promoted_binding_is_recorded_for_digitpos
- Asserts:
  - promoted_bindings has one mapping
  - promoted carrier has binding_id
  - ConditionEnv.binding_id_map[promoted_bid] == promoted_carrier.join_id

Open Follow-ups (Phase 79+)

Wire ScopeManager::lookup_with_binding() into ExprLowerer/ConditionLoweringBox call-sites (so BindingId actually drives resolution).
Extend coverage to Trim and other promotion shapes (additional unit/E2E tests).
Shrink/remove legacy name-based promoted lookup (resolve_promoted_join_id) after call-sites consistently provide BindingId.

3.0 KiB Raw Blame History Unescape Escape