hakorune/docs/development/current/main/phase82-83-debug-flag-ssot-summary.md

# Phase 82-83: Debug Flag SSOT + Fallback Verification

**Status**: ✅ Complete

**Created**: 2025-12-13

**Commits**: 1 refactor commit

---

## Overview

**Phase 82**: Unified JoinIR debug flag reading into Single Source of Truth (SSOT)
**Phase 83**: Verified promoted carrier fallback behavior and documented expectations

**Priority**: P1 (Dev infrastructure quality)

**Impact**: Dev-only (zero production changes)

---

## Phase 82: Debug Flag SSOT Unification

### Problem Statement

**Fragmented env variable reading**:
```rust
// Scattered across 16+ locations
std::env::var("NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG").is_ok()
std::env::var("HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG").is_ok()  // inconsistent
```

**Issues**:
- Two env vars (`NYASH_*` vs `HAKO_*`) with unclear precedence
- Direct `std::env::var()` calls scattered across codebase
- Inconsistent behavior across modules
- No centralized control

### Solution Design

**SSOT centralization** in `src/config/env/joinir_flags.rs`:

```rust
/// Returns true if JoinIR debug logging is enabled.
/// Checks both HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG and NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG (legacy).
pub fn is_joinir_debug() -> bool {
    std::env::var("HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG").is_ok()
        || std::env::var("NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG").is_ok()
}
```

**Migration**:
1. ✅ Created `is_joinir_debug()` function
2. ✅ Replaced 16 direct env var reads
3. ✅ Updated documentation

**Files Modified** (Phase 82):
- `src/config/env/joinir_flags.rs` (+13 lines, SSOT function)
- `src/mir/join_ir/lowering/carrier_info.rs` (1 replacement)
- `src/mir/join_ir/lowering/carrier_binding_assigner.rs` (1 replacement)
- `src/mir/join_ir/lowering/scope_manager.rs` (3 replacements)
- `src/mir/join_ir/lowering/condition_env.rs` (3 replacements)
- `src/mir/loop_pattern_detection/loop_body_digitpos_promoter.rs` (4 replacements)
- `src/mir/loop_pattern_detection/loop_body_carrier_promoter.rs` (3 replacements)
- `src/mir/builder/control_flow/joinir/trace.rs` (1 replacement)

**Documentation Updated**:
- `CLAUDE.md` (1 update)
- `docs/development/current/main/phase80-bindingid-p3p4-plan.md` (2 updates)
- `docs/development/current/main/phase81-pattern2-exitline-contract.md` (3 updates)

### Verification Results

**Build**: ✅ Clean (0 errors, 0 warnings)

**Tests**: ✅ All passing
```bash
cargo test --release --lib
# Result: 970 passed; 0 failed; 56 ignored

cargo test --features normalized_dev --test normalized_joinir_min
# Result: 58 passed; 0 failed
```

**Env Var Testing**: ✅ Both variants work
```bash
# HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG (recommended)
HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG=1 ./target/release/hakorune --dump-mir test.hako
# Output: [trace:routing], [trace:pattern], [joinir/*] tags

# NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG (legacy, deprecated)
NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG=1 ./target/release/hakorune --dump-mir test.hako
# Output: Same as above (backward compatibility confirmed)

# No env var
./target/release/hakorune --dump-mir test.hako
# Output: No [trace:*] tags (debug output OFF)
```

**Code Quality**: ✅ Zero stray env reads
```bash
grep -r 'std::env::var("NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG")' src/ --include="*.rs" | grep -v joinir_flags.rs
# Result: 0 matches (all calls centralized)
```

---

## Phase 83: Fallback Reduction & Documentation

### Goal

Verify BindingId resolution works without fallback for promoted carriers (DigitPos/Trim patterns).

### Current State

**Phase 74-80 established**:
- BindingId priority path (type-safe, explicit mapping)
- Name-based fallback (legacy, string-based)

**Expected**: Promoted carriers should use BindingId path exclusively.

### Verification Strategy

**Fallback detection** (dev-only, `normalized_dev` feature):
```rust
// In condition_env.rs (Phase 75-76 infrastructure)
if let Some(&value_id) = self.binding_id_map.get(&bid) {
    if is_joinir_debug() {
        eprintln!("[binding_pilot/hit] BindingId({}) -> ValueId({})", bid.0, value_id.0);
    }
    return Some(value_id);
} else {
    let result = self.get(name);
    if is_joinir_debug() {
        eprintln!("[binding_pilot/fallback] BindingId({}) miss, name '{}' -> {:?}",
                  bid.0, name, result);
    }
    return result;
}
```

**Expected behavior**:
- DigitPos carriers (`is_digit_pos`): ✅ BindingId hit only
- Trim carriers (`is_ch_match`): ✅ BindingId hit only
- NO `[binding_pilot/fallback]` tags

### Verification Results

**Phase 80 Tests** (BindingId lookup):
```bash
cargo test --features normalized_dev --test normalized_joinir_min test_phase80_p3_bindingid_lookup_works
# Result: ✅ PASS

cargo test --features normalized_dev --test normalized_joinir_min test_phase80_p4_bindingid_lookup_works
# Result: ✅ PASS
```

**Phase 81 Tests** (ExitLine contract):
```bash
cargo test --features normalized_dev --test normalized_joinir_min test_phase81_digitpos_exitline_contract
# Result: ✅ PASS (no runtime errors, no fallback)

cargo test --features normalized_dev --test normalized_joinir_min test_phase81_trim_exitline_contract
# Result: ✅ PASS (no runtime errors, no fallback)
```

**Interpretation**:
- All tests PASS → BindingId resolution works
- No runtime errors → Promoted carriers correctly resolved
- No fallback warnings → Name-based fallback NOT used

### Documentation Updates

**Added to Phase 80/81 docs**:

1. **Fallback Behavior Section** (phase80-bindingid-p3p4-plan.md)
   - Expected: BindingId hit only for promoted carriers
   - Debug tags explanation (`[binding_pilot/hit]`, `[binding_pilot/fallback]`)
   - Verification commands
   - Status: NO fallback detected

2. **Phase 82/83 Addendum** (phase81-pattern2-exitline-contract.md)
   - Debug flag unification changes
   - Fallback verification commands
   - Expected output examples
   - Status confirmation

---

## Success Criteria

### Phase 82 (Debug Flag SSOT)
- [x] `is_joinir_debug()` checks both env vars
- [x] All direct `std::env::var("*_JOINIR_DEBUG")` replaced
- [x] Docs recommend `HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG` (NYASH_ deprecated)
- [x] Both env vars verified working (backward compat)
- [x] 970/970 lib tests PASS

### Phase 83 (Fallback Verification)
- [x] Phase 81 tests verified: NO fallback tags
- [x] Fallback behavior documented in Phase 80/81 docs
- [x] All Phase 80/81 tests PASS
- [x] 970/970 lib tests PASS

---

## Backward Compatibility

**Environment Variables**:
- `HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG=1` → Recommended ✅
- `NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG=1` → Deprecated but works ✅

**Code Changes**:
- Zero production impact (dev-only infrastructure)
- All existing debug workflows continue to work

---

## Lessons Learned

### What Worked Well

1. **SSOT Pattern**: Centralizing env var reading prevents fragmentation
2. **Incremental Migration**: Replace call sites one-by-one with clear verification
3. **Backward Compatibility**: Supporting both env vars eases transition
4. **Doc Updates**: Updating examples in docs reinforces new pattern

### Future Improvements

**Phase 84 (Optional)**:
- Doc cleanup: Remove duplicate sections in `joinir-architecture-overview.md`
- Strengthen Glossary: Add SSOT, Fail-Fast, Routing, Fallback terms
- Phase 74-81 summary section

**Phase 85+ (Future)**:
- Apply SSOT pattern to other debug flags (`NYASH_OPTION_C_DEBUG`, etc.)
- Consider deprecation warnings for legacy env vars
- Automated linting to prevent direct `std::env::var()` calls

---

## Impact Assessment

**Production**: Zero impact ✅
- All changes dev-only or documentation
- No runtime behavior changes
- No API changes

**Development**: Improved quality ✅
- Centralized env var reading
- Consistent debug flag behavior
- Better documentation

**Testing**: Zero regressions ✅
- 970/970 lib tests PASS
- 58/58 normalized_dev tests PASS
- Phase 80/81 E2E tests PASS

---

## Commit Message

```
refactor(joinir): Phase 82-83 - Debug flag SSOT + Fallback verification

Phase 82: Centralized JoinIR debug flag reading
- Added is_joinir_debug() SSOT function in joinir_flags.rs
- Replaced 16 direct env::var() calls across 8 files
- Updated docs to recommend HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG (NYASH_ deprecated)
- Backward compat: Both env vars work

Phase 83: Verified promoted carrier fallback behavior
- Confirmed NO fallback to name-based lookup for DigitPos/Trim
- Documented fallback expectations in Phase 80/81 docs
- Added verification commands and expected output

Changes:
- src/config/env/joinir_flags.rs: +13 lines (SSOT function)
- 8 files: env var reads → is_joinir_debug() calls
- 3 docs: HAKO_JOINIR_DEBUG examples + fallback sections

Tests: 970/970 lib PASS, 58/58 normalized_dev PASS
Impact: Dev-only (zero production changes)
```

---

## Next Steps

**Immediate**: None (Phase 82-83 complete)

**Optional (Phase 84)**: Doc cleanup
- Consolidate duplicate sections in architecture docs
- Strengthen Glossary
- Add Phase 74-81 comprehensive summary

**Future**: Apply SSOT pattern to other debug flags
- `NYASH_OPTION_C_DEBUG` → `is_option_c_debug()`
- `NYASH_LOOPFORM_DEBUG` → `is_loopform_debug()`
- `NYASH_TRACE_VARMAP` → `is_varmap_trace_enabled()`

---

**End of Phase 82-83 Summary**