hakorune/docs/development/current/main/PHASE_75_SUMMARY.md

# Phase 75: BindingId Pilot Integration - Completion Summary

**Status**: ✅ COMPLETE
**Date**: 2025-12-13
**Feature**: `normalized_dev` (dev-only)
**Impact**: Zero production impact

## Executive Summary

Phase 75 successfully implemented a pilot integration of BindingId-based variable lookup in ConditionEnv, demonstrating the "BindingId priority → name fallback" strategy with zero production impact. This completes the second step of the Phase 73-77 migration roadmap.

## Objectives Met

✅ **Primary Goal**: Implement BindingId-based lookup in 1 isolation point (ConditionEnv)
✅ **Secondary Goal**: Demonstrate 3-tier fallback (BindingId → name → None)
✅ **Safety Goal**: Maintain zero production impact (feature-gated)
✅ **Quality Goal**: Comprehensive test coverage (3 new unit tests)

## Implementation Details

### Files Modified (3 files, +170 lines net)

1. **src/mir/join_ir/lowering/scope_manager.rs** (+50 lines)
   - Added `lookup_with_binding()` trait method with default implementation
   - Feature-gated BindingId import

2. **src/mir/join_ir/lowering/condition_env.rs** (+120 lines)
   - Added `binding_id_map: BTreeMap<BindingId, ValueId>` field (feature-gated)
   - Implemented `resolve_var_with_binding()` method
   - Added 3 unit tests (priority/fallback/legacy)
   - Dev logging support (NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG=1)

3. **docs/development/current/main/phase75-bindingid-pilot.md** (new file, ~200 lines)
   - Complete design documentation
   - API reference
   - Test strategy
   - Next steps (Phase 76)

### Key Design Decisions

#### 1. Pilot Integration Point: ConditionEnv

**Rationale**:
- **Isolated Component**: Clear responsibility (condition variable resolution)
- **Well-Tested**: Existing test coverage from Phase 171-fix
- **Simple API**: Single lookup method to extend
- **Representative**: Typical use case for ScopeManager trait

#### 2. 3-Tier Fallback Strategy

```rust
pub fn resolve_var_with_binding(
    &self,
    binding_id: Option<BindingId>,
    name: &str,
) -> Option<ValueId> {
    if let Some(bid) = binding_id {
        // Tier 1: BindingId priority lookup
        if let Some(&value_id) = self.binding_id_map.get(&bid) {
            return Some(value_id);  // [binding_pilot/hit]
        } else {
            // Tier 2: BindingId miss → name fallback
            return self.get(name);  // [binding_pilot/fallback]
        }
    } else {
        // Tier 3: Legacy (no BindingId)
        return self.get(name);      // [binding_pilot/legacy]
    }
}
```

**Benefits**:
- **Incremental Migration**: Legacy code continues to work (Tier 3)
- **Graceful Degradation**: BindingId miss doesn't break (Tier 2)
- **Future-Ready**: BindingId hit path ready for Phase 76+ (Tier 1)

#### 3. ScopeManager Trait Extension

```rust
#[cfg(feature = "normalized_dev")]
fn lookup_with_binding(
    &self,
    binding_id: Option<BindingId>,
    name: &str
) -> Option<ValueId> {
    // Default: BindingId not supported, fall back to name
    let _ = binding_id;
    self.lookup(name)
}
```

**Benefits**:
- **Zero Impact**: Default implementation → existing implementors unaffected
- **Opt-In**: Pattern2ScopeManager can override when ready (Phase 76+)
- **Type Safety**: Trait contract ensures consistent API

## Test Results

### Unit Tests (3 new tests, all PASS)

```
✅ test_condition_env_binding_id_priority  - BindingId hit path
✅ test_condition_env_binding_id_fallback  - BindingId miss → name fallback
✅ test_condition_env_binding_id_none      - Legacy (no BindingId)
```

### Regression Tests

```
✅ cargo test --release --lib
   958/958 PASS (0 failures, 56 ignored)

✅ cargo test --release --lib --features normalized_dev condition_env
   15/15 PASS (including 3 new tests)
```

### Build Verification

```
✅ cargo build --release --lib
   Finished in 48.75s (0 errors, 0 warnings)
```

## Observability

### Dev Logging (NYASH_JOINIR_DEBUG=1)

When BindingId lookup is used (future Phase 76+ integration):

```bash
# BindingId hit
[binding_pilot/hit] BindingId(5) -> ValueId(100) for 'x'

# BindingId miss → fallback
[binding_pilot/fallback] BindingId(99) miss, name 'x' -> Some(ValueId(100))

# Legacy path
[binding_pilot/legacy] No BindingId, name 'x' -> Some(ValueId(100))
```

## Safety Guarantees

### Production Impact: ZERO

1. **Feature Gate**: All BindingId code is `#[cfg(feature = "normalized_dev")]`
2. **Default Behavior**: ScopeManager trait default impl uses name lookup only
3. **Additive Only**: Existing APIs (`lookup()`, `get()`) completely unchanged
4. **No Callers Yet**: `resolve_var_with_binding()` only called from tests (Phase 76+ will add production callers)

### Type Safety

- **BindingId**: Opaque newtype (u32) with overflow checks
- **Option<BindingId>**: Explicit handling of "no BindingId" case
- **BTreeMap**: Deterministic iteration (Phase 222.5-D consistency)

## Next Steps: Phase 76

### Phase 76: Promoted Bindings Migration

**Objective**: Remove `digit_pos → is_digit_pos` naming hack, use promoted_bindings map

**Prerequisites (DONE)**:
- ✅ BindingId infrastructure (Phase 74)
- ✅ ConditionEnv pilot integration (Phase 75)

**Phase 76 Tasks**:
1. Add `promoted_bindings: BTreeMap<BindingId, BindingId>` to CarrierInfo
2. Extend `resolve_var_with_binding()` to check promoted_bindings first
3. Populate promoted_bindings in Pattern2 lowering
4. Remove naming convention hack from CarrierInfo::resolve_promoted_join_id()

**Estimated Effort**: 2-3 hours

**Benefits**:
- **Structural**: Promoted variables tracked by BindingId, not naming convention
- **Type-Safe**: Promoted mapping explicit in CarrierInfo
- **Testable**: Promoted bindings can be verified independently

## Lessons Learned

### What Worked Well

1. **Incremental Approach**: Pilot integration in 1 component validated design without risk
2. **3-Tier Fallback**: Clear strategy for gradual migration (BindingId → name → None)
3. **Feature Gate**: `normalized_dev` kept production code pristine
4. **Test-First**: 3 unit tests ensured correct behavior before lowering integration

### Design Validation

✅ **BindingId Infrastructure (Phase 74)** is solid:
   - `binding_map` correctly populated
   - `allocate_binding_id()` works as expected
   - Shadowing test evidence gives confidence

✅ **Fallback Strategy** is sound:
   - BindingId miss doesn't break (graceful degradation)
   - Legacy path (None) preserves existing behavior
   - Logging helps diagnose which path was taken

✅ **ScopeManager Extension** is flexible:
   - Default impl keeps existing implementors working
   - Opt-in override allows gradual adoption
   - Trait contract ensures API consistency

## References

- **Phase 73**: [phase73-scope-manager-design.md](./phase73-scope-manager-design.md) - Design + PoC
- **Phase 74**: [CURRENT_TASK.md](../../../../CURRENT_TASK.md) - Infrastructure
- **Phase 75**: [phase75-bindingid-pilot.md](./phase75-bindingid-pilot.md) - This implementation
- **Migration Roadmap**: Phase 76-77 (next 4-6 hours)

## Metrics

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| **Files Modified** | 3 |
| **Lines Added** | +170 |
| **New Tests** | 3 |
| **Test Pass Rate** | 100% (961/961) |
| **Production Impact** | 0 (feature-gated) |
| **Implementation Time** | ~1.5 hours |
| **Documentation** | Complete |

---

**Phase 75 Complete**: BindingId pilot integration successfully demonstrated in ConditionEnv with 3-tier fallback, zero production impact, and comprehensive test coverage. Ready for Phase 76 (promoted_bindings migration).