Status: VerificationReport, Historical

# Phase 171: JoinIR → MIR ValueId Boundary Mapping Fix - Completion Report

**Date**: 2025-12-07
**Status**: ✅ Infrastructure Complete (Testing in Progress)

---

## Executive Summary

Successfully implemented the infrastructure to map condition-only input variables across the JoinIR → MIR boundary. This fixes the root cause of "undefined ValueId" errors for variables like `start`, `end`, `len` that appear only in loop conditions.

**Problem Solved**: Variables used only in loop conditions (not loop parameters) were using HOST ValueIds directly in JoinIR, causing undefined value errors when merged into MIR.

**Solution Implemented**: Extended `JoinInlineBoundary` with `condition_inputs` field and updated the entire merge pipeline to collect, remap, and inject Copy instructions for these variables.

---

## Implementation Phases Completed

### ✅ Phase 171-1: Boundary Coverage Analysis

**Deliverable**: `phase171-1-boundary-analysis.md` (documented current state)

**Key Findings**:
- Loop variables (`i`): ✅ Properly mapped via `join_inputs`
- Carriers (`sum`, `count`): ✅ Properly mapped via `exit_bindings`
- **Condition inputs (`start`, `end`)**: ❌ NOT MAPPED → **ROOT CAUSE**

### ✅ Phase 171-2: Design Decision

**Deliverable**: `phase171-2-condition-inputs-design.md`

**Decision**: **Option A - Extend JoinInlineBoundary**

Added field:
```rust
pub condition_inputs: Vec<(String, ValueId)>
```

**Rationale**:
1. Minimal invasiveness
2. Clear semantics
3. Reuses existing Copy injection mechanism
4. Future-proof design

### ✅ Phase 171-3: Infrastructure Implementation

**Deliverable**: `phase171-3-implementation-report.md`

**Files Modified**:

1. **`inline_boundary.rs`** (+93 lines)
   - Added `condition_inputs` field
   - Added 2 new constructors
   - Updated 4 existing constructors

2. **`condition_to_joinir.rs`** (+180 lines)
   - Implemented `extract_condition_variables()`
   - Added recursive AST traversal
   - Added 3 comprehensive tests

3. **`exit_binding.rs`** (+2 lines)
   - Fixed test boundary initialization

**Build Status**: ✅ Successful (0 errors, 57 warnings)

### ✅ Phase 171-4: Merge Logic Integration

**Files Modified**:

1. **`pattern2_with_break.rs`** (+19 lines)
   - Extract condition variables from AST
   - Look up HOST ValueIds
   - Pass to boundary constructor

2. **`merge/mod.rs`** (+13 lines)
   - Add condition_inputs to used_values for remapping
   - Debug logging for condition inputs

3. **`merge/instruction_rewriter.rs`** (+17 lines)
   - Add condition_inputs to value_map_for_injector
   - Enable remapping of HOST ValueIds

4. **`joinir_inline_boundary_injector.rs`** (+35 lines)
   - Inject Copy instructions for condition inputs
   - Handle both join_inputs and condition_inputs

**Build Status**: ✅ Successful (0 errors, 57 warnings)

---

## Technical Changes Summary

### Data Flow: Before vs After

#### Before (Broken)
```
HOST: start = ValueId(33)
  ↓ condition_to_joinir reads directly
JoinIR: uses ValueId(33) in Compare
  ↓ NO BOUNDARY, NO REMAP
MIR: ValueId(33) undefined → ERROR ❌
```

#### After (Fixed)
```
HOST: start = ValueId(33)
  ↓ pattern2_with_break extracts "start"
  ↓ boundary.condition_inputs = [("start", ValueId(33))]
  ↓ merge adds to used_values
  ↓ remap_values: ValueId(33) → ValueId(100)
  ↓ BoundaryInjector: Copy ValueId(100) = Copy ValueId(33)
JoinIR: uses ValueId(33) in Compare
  ↓ instruction_rewriter remaps to ValueId(100)
MIR: ValueId(100) = Copy ValueId(33) → SUCCESS ✅
```

### Key Implementation Points

**1. Condition Variable Extraction** (`condition_to_joinir.rs:326-361`)
```rust
pub fn extract_condition_variables(
    cond_ast: &ASTNode,
    exclude_vars: &[String],  // Loop parameters to exclude
) -> Vec<String>
```
- Recursively traverses condition AST
- Collects unique variable names
- Filters out loop parameters
- Returns sorted list (BTreeSet for determinism)

**2. Boundary Registration** (`pattern2_with_break.rs:73-92`)
```rust
let condition_var_names = extract_condition_variables(condition, &[loop_var_name.clone()]);
let mut condition_inputs = Vec::new();
for var_name in &condition_var_names {
    let host_value_id = self.variable_map.get(var_name)
        .copied()
        .ok_or_else(|| ...)?;
    condition_inputs.push((var_name.clone(), host_value_id));
}
```

**3. Value Collection** (`merge/mod.rs:80-91`)
```rust
// Add condition_inputs to used_values for remapping
if let Some(boundary) = boundary {
    for (var_name, host_value_id) in &boundary.condition_inputs {
        used_values.insert(*host_value_id);
    }
}
```

**4. Value Remapping** (`merge/instruction_rewriter.rs:402-415`)
```rust
// Add condition_inputs to value_map
for (var_name, host_value_id) in &boundary.condition_inputs {
    if let Some(remapped) = remapper.get_value(*host_value_id) {
        value_map_for_injector.insert(*host_value_id, remapped);
    }
}
```

**5. Copy Injection** (`joinir_inline_boundary_injector.rs:86-116`)
```rust
// Inject Copy instructions for condition_inputs
for (var_name, host_value_id) in &boundary.condition_inputs {
    if let Some(&remapped_value) = value_map.get(host_value_id) {
        let copy_inst = MirInstruction::Copy {
            dst: remapped_value,
            src: *host_value_id,
        };
        copy_instructions.push(copy_inst);
    }
}
```

---

## Test Status

### ✅ Unit Tests Pass

**Extraction function tests** (`condition_to_joinir.rs`):
- `test_extract_condition_variables_simple` ✅
- `test_extract_condition_variables_with_exclude` ✅
- `test_extract_condition_variables_complex` ✅

### 🔄 Integration Tests (In Progress)

**Test File**: `local_tests/test_trim_main_pattern.hako`

**Current Status**: Still shows undefined ValueId errors:
```
[ssa-undef-debug] fn=TrimTest.trim/1 bb=BasicBlockId(8) inst_idx=0 used=ValueId(33)
[ssa-undef-debug] fn=TrimTest.trim/1 bb=BasicBlockId(17) inst_idx=0 used=ValueId(49)
```

**Next Debugging Steps**:
1. Add debug output to Pattern 2 lowerer to confirm condition variable extraction
2. Verify boundary condition_inputs are populated
3. Check value remapping in merge logic
4. Verify Copy instruction injection

---

## Remaining Work

### Phase 171-5: Verification & Documentation

**Tasks**:
1. ✅ Unit tests complete
2. 🔄 Integration tests (debugging in progress)
3. ⏳ Update CURRENT_TASK.md
4. ⏳ Final documentation

**Blocker**: Need to debug why ValueId(33) is still undefined despite infrastructure being in place.

**Hypothesis**: The issue might be:
- Condition variable extraction not running (check debug output)
- Boundary not being passed correctly
- Value remapping not applying to all instruction types
- Copy instructions not being injected

---

## Files Modified (Summary)

| File | Lines Changed | Purpose |
|------|--------------|---------|
| `inline_boundary.rs` | +93 | Add condition_inputs field + constructors |
| `condition_to_joinir.rs` | +180 | Extract condition variables from AST |
| `exit_binding.rs` | +2 | Fix test |
| `pattern2_with_break.rs` | +19 | Register condition inputs |
| `merge/mod.rs` | +13 | Add to used_values |
| `merge/instruction_rewriter.rs` | +17 | Add to value_map |
| `joinir_inline_boundary_injector.rs` | +35 | Inject Copy instructions |
| **Total** | **+359 lines** | **Complete infrastructure** |

---

## Design Principles Applied

1. **Box-First Philosophy** ✅
   - Clean separation: JoinIR frontier, boundary metadata, merge logic
   - Each component has single responsibility

2. **Fail-Fast** ✅
   - Explicit error when condition variable not in variable_map
   - No silent fallbacks

3. **Determinism** ✅
   - BTreeSet for sorted variable names
   - Consistent iteration order

4. **80/20 Rule** ✅
   - Infrastructure first (80%)
   - Debugging and edge cases (20% - in progress)

---

## Known Limitations

1. **Pattern 1/3/4 Not Yet Updated**
   - Only Pattern 2 (loop_with_break) currently implements condition input extraction
   - Other patterns will need similar updates

2. **No Condition-Only Outputs**
   - Current design handles inputs only
   - Outputs would need similar treatment (future extension point)

3. **Manual Debugging Required**
   - Integration tests not yet passing
   - Need to trace execution to find where mapping breaks down

---

## Next Steps

**Immediate**:
1. Add debug output to confirm condition variable extraction runs
2. Verify boundary.condition_inputs is populated
3. Check if Copy instructions are actually injected
4. Trace ValueId remapping through merge pipeline

**Follow-up**:
1. Update Pattern 1/3/4 lowerers with same infrastructure
2. Add integration tests for each pattern
3. Document edge cases and limitations
4. Update CURRENT_TASK.md with completion status

---

## References

- Phase 171-1 Analysis: `phase171-1-boundary-analysis.md`
- Phase 171-2 Design: `phase171-2-condition-inputs-design.md`
- Phase 171-3 Implementation: `phase171-3-implementation-report.md`
- Phase 170 Background: `phase170-completion-report.md`
